Atelier Ayesha: Alchemist of the Dusk

I liked this game a lot. The way the story petered out at the end as a sequel hook was disappointing, and as always I wish there was more free time to explore the world, but overall it’s a super solid entry into the series, and it’s more plot-heavy than anything in the Arland trilogy. It tries to be a more traditional jRPG, I think, with decent success, and if you liked the other games you’ll like this, though I don’t think it will convert anyone.

To start, Ayesha is a different type of character than the ones we got in Arland, which is nice. We meet her when she’s already a success, famous as an apothecary who makes medicine that’s sold throughout the land. Unlike the Arland protagonists, her story isn’t coming-of-age, but of using a lifetime’s worth of knowledge.

Her costume is ridiculously pretty and ridiculously impractical.

It’s the shoes that get me the most, tbh. No pants is a given at this point and I’m willing to suspend belief for aesthetic flourishes like the cuffs, but the wedges are just complete nonsensical wtfery to me.

The costuming in general was pretty bad, honestly, definitely worse than in Rorona and Meruru (though not as bad as Totori, mercifully).

A14 Regina
Is this not how prospectors normally dress?

The game also keeps trying to come up with justifications for it, which is annoying. Look, games, when you do this, just admit it’s eyecandy. It’s okay to admit it. I like pretty things, too. I even like pretty men! What I don’t like is insults to my intelligence. So let’s just all accept that the only reason for this is aesthetics and then we’ll tackle the questions that brings up. I promise, saying, “I like pretty women,” will not make anyone take all pretty women from you forever.

Anyway, it’s a shame, because once again this game is absolutely excellent about female friendship and capability, and I really liked the girls, especially Wilbell. I thought the characters were much better than in Totori and the writers dialed everything back to believable levels of quirky, though how this holds through the rest of the sub-trilogy remains to be seen.

Which brings us to the main plot, Ayesha’s search for her sister. Her sister, Nio, goes missing one day while gathering herbs, and is taken for dead. When visiting her grave one day, however, Ayesha sees a young girl whom she believes to be Nio appear, surrounded by glowing flowers. Believing this to be a sign Nio is still alive, Ayesha embarks on a journey to find her. This is a really, really rare plotline — sister saves sister — and it was wonderfully set up.

I also really like the relationship between Keith and Ayesha. He was constantly challenging her and expecting her to rise to the occasion, in a way that made it clear she was smart and capable. He didn’t baby her, and he let her earn his respect based on her accomplishments. The True End [spoilers] where they go off exploring together was a finale I liked[/spoilers], and the game managed to not make him a creeper, which I appreciated.

The biggest weakness of the game was that the plot doesn’t wrap up very well. We don’t really ever get to find out exactly what happened to Nio, what Yggdrasil was, or how or why it was doing what it was. This was all clearly sequel-hook stuff, but I’m not sure why the game had so little confidence in itself it thought withholding plot elements was the only way to get me to spring for the sequel. I expected answers after the final battle, but didn’t really get any. We also don’t really get any followup on the mechanism of the glowing flowers and how or why they were connected to Yggdrasil.

So, yeah, things kind of end with a whimper.

Oh, and this is neither here nor there, but I liked the new monster designs. More foreboding than the Arland ones, and very good at helping to set the tone.

I’m hoping the next two games wrap up the plot with a little more finesse, but it’s hard to tell if that’s going to happen based on the kind of slipshod way it was done here. Nonetheless, this game stands rather well on its own, and you definitely don’t have to play Arland before it, so I think it’d be a great way to experience the series if the more fluffy and sandboxy Arland games didn’t seem your cup of tea.

19 Comments

  1. RandomName says:
    This is a really, really rare plotline — sister saves sister

    But you just read Heaven’s Feel and that was sister saves sister lol

    1. SpoonyViking says:
      Two examples don’t seem like a lot, though.
      1. RandomName says:
        Oh fair enough I just found it funny since she JUST read HF
        1. actonthat says:
          Well there’s also that in HF it’s mostly “boyfriend saves girlfriend” with Rin spending most of the time arguing she should die, while the entire plot of Ayesha is about the sisters helping each other.
          1. SpoonyViking says:
            Good points! So one and half examples?
            1. Roarke says:
              Yes. And, if we include the fact that Hunger Games also kicks off with Katniss saving her sister to become the center of the universe, then that makes a whole 1.51 examples on this blog alone.
              Reply
              1. actonthat says:
                It’s actually interesting that sisters are allowed to be temporarily motivated by each other in both cases, while Ayesha’s full story revolving around Nio is still unique.
              2. Roarke says:
                It’s a sign of how slowly society is getting used to the idea of women as protectors or something, I suppose. I’m not particularly well-read or anything, but… I seriously can’t think of another example. Do want, though.
              3. actonthat says:
                I can’t come up with one, either. Googling around only seems to produce stories that happen to have two sisters in them — Little Women and the like. Googling “story where sister saves sister” brings up news articles… most of which are about a big brother saving his little sister, which is kind of blackly ironic.
              4. SpoonyViking says:
                Off the top of my head, there’s Frozen.
          2. RandomName says:
            Honestly, let’s be real here what role did Shirou play in saving Sakura aside from using Rule Breaker? Honestly none, it was the sisters scene that made Sakura crack and the focus of Heaven’s Feel is Rin and Sakura’s relationship. So 1.75 at least
            1. SpoonyViking says:
              But Rule Breaker was what actually freed Sakura from Angra Mainyu. Plus, we know from one of the bad endings – the one where Rin enforces Shirou’s magical oath – that, without Shirou to stop her, she would have killed Sakura long before that.
              Reply
              1. RandomName says:
                Rule Breaker freed Sakura from AM but the hug was what got Sakura to calm down and realize that yes, people do love her. Also true Day 9 Rin would’ve killed Sakura but RIn’s feelings for Sakura do slowly change throughout the route so by the end she would have saved her.
              2. SpoonyViking says:
                But Rin only has a chance to change her feelings because of Shirou. I see Act’s point: while there is an aspect of “sister saves sister” to HF’s plot, it’s not the most important one when compared to “love interest saves loved one” – especially considering how the route’s central conflict is Shirou abandoning his ideals to save Sakura.
              3. Roarke says:
                Adding this to your good point: If HF was a story of Rin saving Sakura, we wouldn’t have the Normal End. Without Shirou, Sakura explicitly lives a miserable life and dies of old age, whether or not Rin is around.
              4. RandomName says:
                Okay fair enough, I’m willing to see your point. Granted IMO it deserves a half point at least
              5. SpoonyViking says:
                But I did give it a half point. :-)
              6. RandomName says:
                Indeed you did
  2. Zephyr says:
    Hey, Act, this is completely unrelated to the Atelier games, but since you’ve mentioned a few times that you like the pretty outfits, I thought you might be interested in this tea-inspired set of witches I saw the other day.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Skip to toolbar