Very reasonable responses today, including some nice discussion about geopolitics and worldbuilding.
Tag: Pokemon author responses
Random Potshot and Obligative Review: Quivering Lips
Someone who was not Dragon’s Blaze left a counter-review on The Two Colors, Pink and Blue:
“Ok first off don’t listen to this idiot below me Elmo. He rags on every new writer and only targets people with smaller stats. If you look at the stories he’s written well let’s just say he doesn’t practice what he preaches.“
I hoped I could get some reviewing out of them or at least an explanation of what sucked about my stories, but alas this was not to be.
The Other Pokeauthors, Part 106
“As for the whole ‘world’ thing, majority of the time, people don’t bother with that, because it limits who reads the stories since people don’t generally use that search. If I don’t identify it to a world, that allows more people to read it.” THIS IS WHY I HAVE TO DO THIS.
The Other Pokeauthors, Part 105
“And since part of your penname is Elmo yeah dude Elmo is for kids not adults. So grow up!”
Responses are otherwise appreciative, including a few messages in support of me re: the Blaze conflict.
The Other Pokeauthors, Part 104
Super chill responses today. The worst I’ve got is someone upset at Blaze’s review abuse.
The Other Pokeauthors, Part 103
Very few responses today, but the ones I get are pretty good. I guess I’ll just have to assume everyone’s being chill!
The Other Pokeauthors, Part 102
A revenge review, and otherwise polite responses.
The Other Pokeauthors, Part 101
Responses are mostly appreciative.
Honey vs. Vinegar Responses
Enki fared quite well with their responses.
Edit: At Enki’s request, full messages will not be shown to preserve respondents’ privacy.
The Other Pokeauthors, Part 100
“Stop poking around at other people’s grammar, especially if yours is in the same state. No one is perfect. Not even you, as you have typed “you’re” as opposed to “you are”, for instance.”
The Other Pokeauthors, Part 99
“Not to mention the amounts of YOUR FanFiction’s that have flaws and even contain language in the summary? Talk about my summaries not having any detail, you need to look at the large variety of yours. Literally one of them only has a few words that doesn’t tell the reader a thing!” This was followed by absolutely no clarification, naturally.
The Other Pokeauthors, Part 98
“It’s amazing that you don’t know anything about writing.” Responses are otherwise appreciative, however.
Pokeauthors Special Spotlight: Another Verse
Someone from back when I first started discovered I was still at it and gave me the same non-advice everyone always does.
The Other Pokeauthors, Part 97
“If I built, and designed, a beautiful mansion and it collapses down a sinkhole the whole world will know.”
Edit: A new revenge review snuck in at the last minute!
The Other Pokeauthors, Part 96
“I couldn’t care less how you feel about my grammar use. I’m having fun and that’s what matters.”
And another author insists that I’m doing reviewing wrong without providing anything new.